Research · run
We asked ChatGPT for the best SEO consultant in 60 cities. It named the local one once.
We picked 60 independent SEO consultants and one-to-three-person SEO shops, each in its own city across the US, Canada, the UK, Ireland, Australia and New Zealand. For every city we asked ChatGPT, with web search on, who the best SEO consultants there are. Then we checked whether the answer named the local consultant, and which sources it cited.
Headline findings
1 of 60
answers named the local consultant we checked
44 of 60
answers cited at least one directory or listing site
3.4
cited source domains per answer, on average
In our test, the consultant's own site was almost never what ChatGPT reached for. The sources it did cite were mostly agency directories and review listings, the same few again and again.
The sources ChatGPT cited most
Number of the 60 answers that cited each domain.
| Source | Type | Answers citing it |
|---|---|---|
| clutch.co | Agency directory and reviews | 28 |
| themanifest.com | Agency directory | 16 |
| expertise.com | Local business directory | 7 |
| agencies.semrush.com | Agency directory | 7 |
| designrush.com | Agency directory | 7 |
| reviews.birdeye.com | Review listings | 5 |
| goodfirms.co | Agency directory and reviews | 3 |
| reddit.com | Forum | 2 |
Download: source counts (CSV). It holds the aggregate counts above only; we do not publish which consultants were in the sample.
What a consultant or local business can do about it
None of these guarantees a mention. They are the places this test says ChatGPT was looking.
- Check the directories that were cited. Search clutch.co, themanifest.com, expertise.com, agencies.semrush.com and designrush.com for your business. If you have a profile, complete it: services, city, and a plain description. If you have none, decide which ones fit your business.
- Get reviews there. Several of the cited sources are review platforms, so a profile with real client reviews has more to show than an empty one.
- Say the city and the service plainly on your own site. A services or location page that states "SEO consultant in [city]" in its title and first lines is easy for a search-enabled assistant to match to a question like ours.
- Make sure ChatGPT's search crawler can read your site. ChatGPT search uses OAI-SearchBot; check that robots.txt does not block it with the free AI crawler check.
- Ask ChatGPT about your own business. The free Does ChatGPT cite my site? check asks it one buyer question and shows whether you are named, and which sources it cited instead.
Method
- Sample: 60 independent SEO consultants and one-to-three-person SEO shops, one per city, across the US, Canada, the UK, Ireland, Australia and New Zealand.
- Question: asked once per city, with the city filled in: "Who are the best SEO consultants or small SEO agencies in <city>? Name specific firms."
- Engine: ChatGPT with web search on, through SEO Sets' own ChatGPT engine, on 18 November 2026. One run per city, one engine.
- Named: the answer counted as naming the consultant when it named their business or cited their site.
- Sources: the domains in the answer's own cited-source list, counted once per answer.
Caveats
- Small sample. 60 cities, one consultant each.
- One run per city. AI answers change from run to run; ask the same question tomorrow and the answer, and its sources, may differ.
- One engine. This is ChatGPT only. Perplexity, Claude and Gemini were not part of this test.
- Not a random sample. The consultants were our own outreach prospects, not a random draw of SEO consultants.
- Our result, not a rule. This shows what happened in our test. It does not show that ChatGPT never recommends local consultants.
Related: which popular sites block AI crawlers, our weekly robots.txt study.
Does ChatGPT name your business?
Run the free check: one buyer question to ChatGPT, with web search on, and the sources it cited instead of you. No account needed. A free SEO Sets account connects your Google Search Console and shows your top 3 pages with the most search upside. No credit card.
Frequently asked questions
Does ChatGPT ever recommend local SEO consultants?
Sometimes. In our test it named the local consultant we were checking in 1 of 60 answers. One run per city is a small sample, and AI answers change from run to run, so treat this as a snapshot, not a rule.
Where does ChatGPT get its local recommendations?
When web search is on, ChatGPT lists the pages it used. In our test, 44 of 60 answers cited at least one directory or listing site, and clutch.co alone was cited in 28 answers. Answers cited 3.4 source domains on average.
How were the 60 consultants chosen?
Not at random. They were independent SEO consultants and one-to-three-person SEO shops we were already looking at as outreach prospects, each in their own city across the US, Canada, the UK, Ireland, Australia and New Zealand. We do not publish who they are.
Can I check whether ChatGPT names my business?
Yes. The free "Does ChatGPT cite my site?" check asks ChatGPT, with web search on, one buyer question and shows whether the answer links or names your site, and which sources it cited instead. No account needed.